A woman found dead in her home was likely killed by her own Great Dane dogs, police say.
Mary Matthews, 49, was found in her Clearcreek Township home in Ohio, US, on Friday, local police told CNN affiliate WLWT.
Watch in the video above: 10-year-old child mauled by pack of dogs
The cause of death has been determined to be a “dog attack,” Clearcreek Township police chief John Terrill told WLWT.
Matthews suffered multiple wounds, according to an incident report.
Investigators found two “large but thin” Great Danes on an enclosed deck of the home and blood was present throughout the house, according to WLWT.
More on 7NEWS.com.au:
Matthews’ husband, Mark Matthews, found his wife unresponsive in the home Friday and called authorities.
He had been in county jail since Wednesday and returned home that day, authorities said.
Mark Matthews said the family rescued the dogs about two years ago but one had recently become vicious, biting his arm, WLWT reported.
“I wanted to get rid of him, but she wouldn’t,” Mark Matthews told the affiliate.
“She loves animals.”
Authorities believe that the dogs attacked the woman and she was able to put them outside before succumbing to her injuries.
Police believe she may not have realised the severity of her injuries and there was evidence that she had changed her clothing as well as attempted to clean up the blood with towels.
‘I wanted to get rid of him, but she wouldn’t … she loves animals.’
Police said the victim suffered from chronic alcoholism and took several prescription medications, which may have impacted her ability to respond to the situation appropriately, according to WLWT.
Dogs put down
“Due to this history, it is felt that (Mary Matthews) may not have been in a clear-minded state to judge the severity of her situation and thus failed to call for help,” the police report said.
WLWT reported that the dogs were euthanised.
Plane full of passengers from coronavirus epicentre in China lands in Sydney
Hundreds of passengers today arrived in Australia from the Chinese city of Wuhan, the epicentre of a new deadly virus which is spreading around the world.
Passengers from China Eastern flight MU749 were wearing masks as they made their way through Sydney Airport’s arrivals hall just before midday after a 10-hour night flight on an A332 plane that can hold 234 people.
The flight was one of the last to leave the city of 11million before a quarantine was put in place and all outbound trains and planes were cancelled.
The passengers were screened in China before they boarded and, when their aircraft landed, they were asked by the pilot to declare if they felt unwell.
NSW Health had a team of four nurses and doctors, who wore masks but not full HAZMAT suits, at the airport to interview passengers and ask them if they had any cold-like symptoms before they went through customs.
The passengers were also screened by thermal imaging to check their temperatures – and given leaflets in English and Mandarin telling them to see a doctor if they suffered sweats, breathing difficulties or chills.
A plan was in place to take any passenger suspected of being infected to Westmead Hospital – but nobody was found to be sick.
Passengers from the final flight from Wuhan – the epicentre of the coronavirus – are seen walking through arrivals at Sydney Airport on Thursday
The flight captain (left) and other flight staff (right) were seen walking through the arrivals hall after getting off the plane
The passengers from China Eastern flight MU749 were wearing masks as they made their way through Sydney Airport’s arrivals hall
The passengers were screened in China before they boarded and, when their aircraft landed, they were asked by the pilot to declare if they felt unwell. Pictured: Children at Sydney Airport wearing masks
NSW Health had a team of four nurses and doctors, who wore masks but not full HAZMAT suits, at the airport to interview anyone who had cold-like symptoms before they went through customs. Pictured: Children at Sydney Airport wearing masks
Medical staff check the body temperature of passengers as they arrive at a railway station in Yingtan City, Jiangxi province, China as part of precautions regarding the virus outbreak
The flight’s cabin crew are pictured walking into arrivals wearing gloves. Workers at the Sydney Airport information desk said they had been told by their bosses not to speak to the media under any circumstances
This is the leaflet that passengers were given when they landed in Australia after flying from the Chinese city of Wuhan
One international student from Wuhan who was on the flight told Daily Mail Australia he was quizzed by officials on the way into the airport.
‘A group of doctors wearing masks asked me if I had a cold and if I felt unwell, which I didn’t,’ he said.
‘They checked my temperature and then let me through. I got lucky because I’m on the last flight out of Wuhan.
‘The situation isn’t that bad there, it’s not as bad as all the scare stories.’
Another passenger said they realised the situation was serious in Wuhan when the city was isolated.
Dozens of the passengers are likely to be visiting Australia as tourists or for family re-unions ahead of the Lunar New Year on Saturday
China Eastern flight MU749 arrives on the tarmac at Sydney International Airport in Sydney on Thursday from Wuhan
‘I was shocked when I heard that flights and trains were cancelled. To tell people not to leave during New Year is a drastic measure.’
One passenger said officials went up and down the plane when it landed, quizzing all the passengers.
‘They checked everyone but I wasn’t really worried,’ she said.
A passenger named Kevin Ouyang, who held up his information leaflet as he posed for photos, said people travelling to Australia are worried about going home if the virus spreads.
‘People are very worried,’ he said. ‘It’s a big city.’
Flight crew were seen walking through the arrivals hall with masks and gloves. The captain, wearing sunglasses and a mask, was directed though the hall as a scrum of photographers took pictures.
Dozens of the passengers are likely to be visiting Australia as tourists or for family re-unions ahead of the Lunar New Year on Saturday, raising fears they will be traveling to places with large crowds such as Bondi Beach and the Sydney Opera House.
Staff working at shops in the arrivals hall said they were on high alert as the flight from Wuhan landed.
One mobile phone shop worker, who asked not to be named, told Daily Mail Australia: ‘We’re very concerned about it and we’re taking precautions such as regularly washing our hands’.
A currency exchange worker said she was concerned because she had been getting more ill more than usual since working in the airport.
She said: ‘It’s really scary and I’m really worried about the virus because it’s easy for us working in the airport to catch infections. I would say I get a cold every few weeks – just because of the number of people passing through.
‘Cancelling flights from Wuhan is a good thing,’ she added.
Workers at the Sydney Airport information desk said they had been told by their bosses not to speak to the media under any circumstances.
The new coronavirus was discovered in Wuhan last month. It is believed to have spread from animals in the city’s market and has already killed 17 and spread to five countries including the US.
Doctors on Wednesday said the number of cases around the world may be as high as 10,000.
Today’s flight from Wuhan was the last one to enter Sydney before the quarantine imposed by the Chinese government.
‘The rise in the mobility of the public has objectively increased the risk of the epidemic spreading,’ Chinese National Health Commission vice minister Li Bin said.
Experts fear the new coronavirus, which is not yet named, may already be in Australia even though no-one in the country has been diagnosed.
An expert said even using thermal imaging to detect passengers with high temperatures may not stop the virus getting into Australia. Right: Kevin Ouyang shows a the leaflet passengers received when getting off the place
In a chilling warning, professor of global biosecurity at UNSW Dr Raina McIntyre said even using thermal imaging to detect passengers with high temperatures may not stop the virus getting into Australia
In an interview with Daily Mail Australia on Thursday morning, Dr Raina McIntyre, professor of global biosecurity at UNSW, said: ‘It is possible that someone who is incubating the infection but is not yet ill is in the country.
‘People can be incubating the disease and not have fever when they enter the country.’
In a chilling warning, Dr McIntyre said even using thermal imaging to detect passengers with high temperatures may not stop the virus getting into Australia.
She said: ‘Some infections involve transmission of virus before any symptoms appear – influenza is a classic example of this.’
Chinese authorities say 17 people have died and more than 500 have been infected, air and rail departures from Wuhan are suspended from January 23
‘SARS, Ebola and MERS CoV tend to only be infectious when people are sick and have clear symptoms, so thermoscanning is more useful in such infections. We do not know yet whether this new coronavirus can be spread in the absence of symptoms. If it is like SARS, it is unlikely, but this needs to be confirmed with research.’
Dr McIntyre said that new measures must be put in place to stop the deadly infection spreading, including new triage protocols in hospitals.
She said: ‘What would really help detect cases and prevent outbreaks is automated triage protocols in emergency departments and general practice – where if a patient presents with fever, health workers are prompted to ask if they have travelled recently.
Passengers were expected to be welcomed by a crack team at Sydney Airport including four NSW Health doctors and nurses experienced in public health and infection control
‘If they have, and if they have returned from China, this would then trigger a protocol for isolating the patient and contacting relevant health authorities.
‘Time and time again we see failure of hospital triage when travel history is not asked – MERS CoV in South Korea for example – resulting in preventable epidemics. Providing returning passengers with information cards on who to contact should they develop symptoms is also useful.’
The Chinese city of Wuhan was placed under quarantine on Thursday four hours after China Eastern flight MU749 took off in an effort to stop the spread of the killer coronavirus believed to have originated there.
No one will be allowed to enter or leave Wuhan, a city of 11 million in China’s Hubei province, as one of the country’s busiest travel seasons surrounding the Lunar New Year kicks off.
The crack team at Sydney Airport were set to include four NSW Health doctors and nurses experienced in public health and infection control alongside virology experts from Westmead Hospital and elsewhere.
The Chinese city of Wuhan was placed under quarantine on Thursday in an effort to stop the spread of the killer coronavirus believed to have originated there. A plane carrying hundreds of passengers from the city to Sydney has landed on Thursday
Taiwan’s Center for Disease Control (CDC) personnel use thermal scanners to screen passengers arriving on a flight from China’s Wuhan province
A lady answers questions to the media as passengers arrive at Sydney International Airport after a flight from Wuhan
The team were due to wear masks and gloves when examining anyone with symptoms, NSW Health protection executive director Jeremy McAnulty said.
‘If it looks like they may have an infection … we can arrange for testing and management of that person right away,’ Dr McAnulty said.
Experts at Westmead Hospital can rapidly diagnose patients although if someone is very unwell they could be taken to a hospital closer to the airport.
Dr McAnulty said identifying potential carriers at the airport was ‘not foolproof by any means’ because people who’ve been exposed to the virus may not display symptoms for days.
The virus, an as-yet unnamed variant of the coronavirus, was first detected in Wuhan, China last month but has now breached China’s borders
The virus is thought to have spread into humans from a Wuhan seafood market ‘which illegally traded wild animals’ before travelers carried it to at least five other countries – Thailand, Taiwan, South Korea, Japan and the United States.
World Health Organization (WHO) officials met Wednesday to decide whether to declare the outbreak a ‘public health emergency of international concern’, but members’ opinions were ‘split’ and the committee will reconvene Thursday.
Experts say its possible up to 10,000 people in China alone have been exposed to the virus, called 2019-nCoV, which is from the same family that caused previous outbreaks of SARS and MERS, killing hundreds of people in dozens of countries.
China’s National Health Commission said the virus had been mutating, making it more difficult to control.
Wuhan will temporarily shut down airport and train stations for outgoing passengers as authorities attempt to control the spread of the virus.
Residents have been urged not to leave the city, however, as it is the Lunar New Year holiday many will be planning trips.
‘If it’s not necessary we suggest that people don’t come to Wuhan,’ Wuhan’s mayor Zhou Xianwang said.
Chinese residents wear masks while waiting at a bus station near the closed Huanan Seafood Wholesale Market, which has been linked to the outbreak that started in December
WHAT DO WE KNOW ABOUT THE CORONAVIRUS OUTBREAK SO FAR?
A total of 532 people are confirmed to have caught the unnamed coronavirus, which has never been seen before. Seventeen patients have died.
Most of the cases have occurred in Wuhan, a city in Hubei province home to 11million people. But patients have been diagnosed across China, including in Beijing and Shanghai.
The coronavirus, which is from the same family as SARS, has also spread to South Korea, Thailand, Japan and Taiwan.
Chinese officials yesterday confirmed the virus has spread between humans, suggesting it can be passed through coughs and sneezes.
The outbreak is believed to have started late last month among people connected to a seafood market in Wuhan, which has since been shut.
China is entering its busiest travel period due to the Lunar New Year, which sees many people travelling back to their home town or village.
Virologists fear the increased travel that will happen over the holidays will cause a surge in cases.
Cancer con Belle Gibson seen at Melbourne Ethiopian community meeting
A video has surfaced of cancer con-woman Belle Gibson at a Melbourne-based Ethiopian community group meeting.
The discovery of the vision comes a day after the 28-year-old’s Northcote home was raided and assets seized.
The raid was in an effort to recoup part of a $500,000 fine she received for falsely claiming she cured herself of brain cancer through diet and alternative therapies.
In the video, posted on Facebook by Shabo Media in October, a headscarf-clad Gibson goes by the name Sabontu and speaks at length about the ongoing plight of the Oromo people from “back home” in Ethiopia.
The Federal Court fined Gibson $410,000 in 2017 for breaching consumer law when she claimed she had brain cancer but healed herself through diet and alternative therapies, going on to make a profit from her cookbook The Whole Pantry and an app with the same name.
Gibson received $440,500 from sales of her app and book but donated only about $10,000.
More on 7NEWS.com.au
Her fine has now grown to more than half a million dollars with costs and interest.
Gibson appeared in the Federal Court last year claiming she was unable to pay the fine, despite a financial analysis showing she spent about $91,000 between 2017 and 2019, including $13,000 on clothes, cosmetics and accessories.
Adam Schiff calls Trump a DESPOT as he begins Democrats’ case to remove the president
President Donald Trump tried to paint pursuer Adam Schiff as a pitiful Looney Tunes character Wednesday as Democrats sketched out their case against him in his impeachment trial – while a team of lawmakers used their own color TV snippets to ensnare the president.
Flying back from Switzerland, Trump retweeted a cartoon short in the style of a Coyote and Road Runner cartoon. His aide Dan Scavino had earlier tweeted it out during the president’s trip overseas.
The 90-second sketch did its best to ridicule the impeachment trial that Democrats have described as a serious affair with grave stakes for the republic. In the cartoon, which offers apologize to cartoon great Chuck Jones, the California impeachment manager is drawn with computer animation to look represent Wile E. Coyote, who just can’t seem to land his prey.
Instead, Schiff T. Coyote ends up getting crushed under a giant boulder, slammed by a catapult bearing the name of former special counsel Robert Mueller, and nearly run down by the ‘Trump Non Stop’ 2020 Express train.
President Donald Trump retweeted a video depicting impeachment manager Rep. Adam Schiff as the hapless Wile E. Coyote
Trump’s effort to ridicule his impeachment trial came as allies, including GOP Rep. Mark Meadows, said the affair was redundant and compared it to an Andy Griffith repeat.
But the president wasn’t the only one using video to effect. Democratic House impeachment managers used their first day of fully making their case against Trump to use video clips, often to harsh effect.
They made their first use of a Fox News video clip by Trump lawyer Rudy Giuliani, and frequently played clips of the president himself to seated senators who appeared to perk up whenever impeachment managers turned to media.
‘Keep your eye on Ukraine,’ Giuliani can be heard saying on ‘Fox and Friends’ in April 2019. ‘Because in Ukraine a lot of the dirty work was done in digging up the information. American officials were used. Ukrainian officials were used. That’s like collusion with the Ukrainians. Actually in this case conspiracy with the Ukrainians,’ Giuliani said.
One sketch shows Rep. Schiff getting whipped by a catapult as he tries to pursue the speedy Road Runner (Trump)
The 90-second sketch made fun of cast Schiff as unable to take out Trump, a day after Republicans voted against a series of Democratic attempts to get witnesses and documents in the impeachment trial
Democrats made their own use of video, including playing clips of Trump saying he would accept oppo research from a foreign government
In this screengrab taken from a Senate Television webcast, House impeachment manager Rep. Sylvia Garcia (D-TX) speaks during impeachment proceedings against U.S. President Donald Trump. She played video of Trump lawyer Rudy Giuliani
‘I think you’ll get some interesting information about Joe Biden from Ukraine. About his son Hunter Biden. About a company he was on the board of for years, which may be one of the most crooked companies in Ukraine,’ said the president’s lawyer and former New York mayor.
Democrats call Trump and his team’s efforts to push Ukraine to investigate Biden, a leading political rival, a centerpiece of their abuse of power impeachment article.
Impeachment managers also made regular use of Trump’s own words.
Sens. Ted Cruz, John Cornyn, and other Republicans looked straight at screens set up inside the Senate chamber to hear Trump himself asking ‘Russia, if you’re listening’ to please get Hillary Clinton’s missing emails.
Cruz was a leading rival for Trump for the Republican nomination in 2016. On Wednesday he issued a forceful call to hear from Hunter Biden, the surviving son of Vice President Joe Biden, as a witness.
Impeachment manager Rep. Sylvia Garcia of Texas played video clips of Trump’s interview with ABC’s George Stephanopolous, who asked if he would accept opposition research from a foreign government like Russia or China or call the FBI.
‘I think maybe you do both. I think maybe you might want to listen. There’s nothing wrong with listening,’ Trump said, in comments broadcast inside the Senate chamber and to viewing audiences.
‘I think I’d want to hear it,’ he explained. ‘It’s not an interference. They had information – I think I’d take it.’
She accused Giuliani of trying to press Ukraine to do Trump’s ‘political dirty work.’
She said he was trying to push ‘politically motivated investigations’ as part of a ‘quid pro quo.’
Senate Minority Leader Charles Schumer gave a stellar review to Schiff, calling his opening statement a ‘tour de force.’ By the around 10 pm after hours of argument, Schiff implored senators to seek additional administration documents that are known to exist. ‘The only question is – do you want to hear it now?’ he asked – to find out ‘how far this corruption goes.’
Trump legal team member Rep. Mark Meadows was unpersuaded, casting the third-ever presidential impeachment trial as a snooze-fest.
‘The troubling thing to many of us is actually staying alert enough to be able to follow it,’ he told reporters in the Capitol basement. ‘You know the punchline to this joke. You can’t even pay attention,’ he continued. ‘I would suggest that the American people – if they could turn their channel and watch something else, that’s what they’re doing.’
Meadows told DailyMail.com the Democrats’ use of video clips wasn’t effective, making still another TV analogy.
‘Thirteen million people have already seen those videos not once but twice, so I don’t know that it’s affective at all. There’s only so much you can do reruns, unless you’re Andy Griffith. At this particular point, Adam Schiff reruns are not getting good ratings,’ he posited.
During his initial presentation of the case for impeachment, Schiff likened Trump to a despot, claiming that the conduct the articles charge the president with committing is exactly what the framers of the Constitution were trying to prevent.
‘Over the coming days, you will hear remarkably consistent evidence of President Trump’s corrupt scheme and cover-up,’ he told senators, who are sitting as jurors to hear two impeachment articles against Trump.
Schiff said the Founders knew what it was like to live under monarchical rule, and said they created impeachment to make sure that never happened in America.
‘We should not imagine for one moment that they lacked basic common sense,’ Schiff said of the framers. ‘Or refuse to apply it ourselves. They knew what it was like to live under a despot and risked their lives to be free of it.’
‘They knew they were creating a powerful executive and needed to constrain it,’ he continued. ‘They did not intend for the power of impeachment to be used frequently or over mere matters of policy but they put it in the constitution for a reason.’
The Senate convened Wednesday afternoon for the second day of the trial where Democrats started to argue the case for removing the president from office for abuse of power and obstruction of Congress.
Trump had mocked the trial as a ‘hoax’ at a press conference before he flew home from the World Economic Forum in Davos, but said he had watched ‘between meetings.’
He has the Republican senators so far in lockstep behind him, voting down a marathon attempt to force witnesses and evidence to be admitted before the opening arguments, and many publicly speaking in support of him Wednesday before going to the chamber for the trial.
But Democrats are determined to put his words center stage and ran a series of videos of his public statements during Schiff’s more than two-hour long opening statement.
Adam Schiff said during his opening remarks during the second day of the Senate impeachment trial that Donald Trump is a ‘despot’
While speaking from the Senate Floor, Adam Schiff, who is leading the Democratic prosecution team, said that Trump is what the Founding Fathers fear most, which is why, he says, the included the provision of impeachment and removal
The Democrats then put on-screen a portion of a letter Alexander Hamilton sent to George Washington detailing a sort of president that they might want to be removed from office
Retired Navy Chaplain Barry Black (right) also called for ‘civility’ in his prayer on the Senate floor after Chief Justice John Roberts (left) had to reprimand Senators for verbally sparring. Roberts reminded members on Tuesday to ‘avoid speaking in a manner and using language that is not conducive to civil discourse’
Front and center: Democrats repeatedly showed footage of Trump over the years to make their case
Schiff said Trump is what the founding fathers feared most. He detailed what sort of president for which they imagined impeachment would be used.
‘For a man who would subvert the interests of the nation to pursue his own interests, a man who would perpetuate to seek office by cheating at an election,’ Schiff detailed. ‘A man who would seek constitutional limit and defeating branches of government in their co-equal powers and the man who thought it gave him the right to do anything he wanted and practice in the art of deception. A man believed he was above the law and beholden to no one.’
HOW ADAM SCHIFF QUOTED ALEXANDER HAMILTON TO ATTACK DONALD TRUMP
Schiff quoted from a letter Hamilton (left) sent to Washington (right) in August 1792:
‘When a man unprincipled in private life desperate in his fortune, bold in his temper, possessed of considerable talents, having the advantage of military habits – despotic in his ordinary demeanor – known to have scoffed in private at the principles of liberty- when such a man is seen to mount the hobby horse of popularity- to join in the cry of danger to liberty -to take every opportunity of embarrassing the General Government & bringing it under suspicion- to flatter and fall in with all the non sense of the zealots of the day – It may justly be suspected that his object is to throw things into confusion that he may ride the storm and direct the whirlwind.’
Hamilton was most likely attacking his – ultimately deadly – rival Burr but the letter as whole spelled out his battle over his First Bank of the United States and his plan for a national mint. He saw its fierce critics Thomas Jefferson and James Madison as threatening the fragile new USA by making federal government impossible – and he feared that would open the way to a demagogue seizing power and doing away with democracy
‘A man in short would be a king,’ Schiff said. ‘We are here today in this hallowed chamber, undertaking this solemn action for only the third time in history because Donald J. Trump, the 43rd president of the United States, has acted precisely as Hamilton and his contemporaries feared.’
Schiff, who is leading the House Democrats team of prosecutors, read the Constitutional Remedy, which Alexander Hamilton wrote in a letter to George Washington, to describe Trump.
‘When a man unprincipled in private life desperate in his fortune, bold in his temper, possessed of considerable talents, having the advantage of military habits, despotic in his ordinary demeanor, known to have scoffed in private at the principles of liberty, when such a man is seen to mount the hobbyhorse of popularity, to join in the cry of danger to liberty, to take every opportunity of embarrassing the general government and bringing it under suspicion, to flatter and fall in with all the nonsense of the zealots of the day, it may be justly be suspected his object is to throw things into confusion, that he might ride the storm and direct the while wind,’ Schiff quoted at the start of his remarks Wednesday.
Right before heading into the Senate chamber, the House Intelligence chairman said the president was ‘bragging’ about hiding relevant information to the impeachment trial.
‘The President, late last night or early this morning – depending on where you are in the world – bragged that he thought things were going well because they had all the materials. Well, indeed they do have the material hidden from the American people. That is nothing to brag about,’ Schiff hit at Trump.
Before Schiff’s remarks, retired Navy Chaplain Barry Black, 71, called for ‘civility’ in his prayer before the senators, prosecution, defense and presiding Chief Justice John Roberts.
‘Sovereign god, author of liberty, we gather in this historic chamber for the solemn responsibility of these impeachment proceedings. Give wisdom to the distinguished chief justice John Roberts, as he presides,’ he prayed. ‘Lord, you are all powerful and know our thoughts before we form them.’
‘As our lawmakers have become jurors, remind them of your admonition in first corinthians 10:31, that whatever they do should be done for your glory,’ he continued. ‘Help them remember that patriots reside on both sides of the aisle, that words have consequences and that how something is said can be as important as what is said. Give them a civility built upon integrity that brings consistency in their beliefs and actions. We pray in your powerful name. Amen.’
Chuck Schumer said just hours before the hearing kicked-off that Senate Democrats would continue to push for witnesses in Donald Trump’s impeachment trial but ruled out the potential of Hunter Biden being one of those individuals called.
‘Look the bottom line is that the witnesses should have something to do with and direct knowledge of the charges against the president,’ The Senate minority leader told reporters gathered in the Capitol Wednesday morning.
‘You know, we don’t need to have witnesses that have nothing to do with this that are trying to distract Americans from the truth,’ he said, suggesting that witnesses the president and Republicans have pushed for, including Hunter Biden, are not relevant to the case.
Senator Minority Leader Chuck Schumer said Wednesday that Democrats would continue to push for the ability to call witnesses in the impeachment trial
He ruled out, however the potential of allowing Republicans to call Joe Biden or his son Hunter, claiming they ‘have nothing to do with this’
Democrats have floated calling both acting Chief of Staff Mick Mulvaney (left) and former national security adviser John Bolton (right) as witnesses in the impeachment trial
But Republicans have claimed they want to hear from both former Vice President Joe Biden and his son Hunter if witnesses are called
Trump has said he wants to hear from the anonymous whistle-blower whose report led to the launch of the impeachment inquiry in the first place
READ THE ARTICLES OF IMPEACHMENT AGAINST DONALD TRUMP
In 1,414 words, the articles of impeachment passed by the House of Representatives lay out two charges against President Donald Trump.
Article I: Abuse of Power
Using the powers of his high office, President Trump solicited the interference of a foreign government, Ukraine, in the 2020 United States Presidential election.
He did so through a scheme or course of conduct that included soliciting the Government of Ukraine to publicly announce investigations that would benefit his reelection, harm the election prospects of a political opponent, and influence the 2020 United States Presidential election to his advantage.
President Trump also sought to pressure the Government of Ukraine to take these steps by conditioning official United States Government acts of significant value to Ukraine on its public announcement of the investigations.
President Trump engaged in this scheme or course of conduct for corrupt purposes in pursuit of personal political benefit. In so doing, President Trump used the powers of the Presidency in a manner that compromised the national security of the United States and undermined the integrity of the United States democratic process.’
Article II: Obstruction of Congress
As part of this impeachment inquiry, the Committees undertaking the investigation served subpoenas seeking documents and testimony deemed vital to the inquiry from various Executive Branch agencies and offices, and current and former officials.
In response, without lawful cause or excuse, President Trump directed Executive Branch agencies, offices, and officials not to comply with those subpoenas. President Trump thus interposed the powers of the Presidency against the lawful subpoenas of the House of Representatives, and assumed to himself functions and judgments necessary to the exercise of the ‘sole Power of Impeachment’ vested by the Constitution in the House of Representatives.
In the history of the Republic, no President has ever ordered the complete defiance of an impeachment inquiry or sought to obstruct and impede so comprehensively the ability of the House of Representatives to investigate ‘high Crimes and Misdemeanors.”
This abuse of office served to cover up the President’s own repeated misconduct and to seize and control the power of impeachment — and thus to nullify a vital constitutional safeguard vested solely in the House of Representatives.
Schumer comments came just hours before the Senate is set to begin the second day of the impeachment trial against Donald Trump for abuse of power and obstruction of Congress.
When asked if he would cut a deal with Republicans to allow former Vice President Joe Biden and his son Hunter to testify in exchange for witnesses Democrats want, like former national security adviser John Bolton and acting Chief of Staff Mick Mulvaney, Schumer deflected.
The New York Democrat said instead, that they were focused on first obtaining the ability to call witnesses in the first place.
‘Right now we haven’t heard them wanting any witnesses at all,’ Schumer said of Republicans. ‘So our first quest is to continue to focus our efforts and focus the American people on leaning for a fair trial, which means witnesses and documents. Witnesses and documents that, again, reflect the truth.’
Schumer didn’t rule out the possibility that some evidence might come forward that would lead to even Democrat support for Trump’s acquittal.
‘And the bottom line is this: we don’t know what these witnesses and documents will reveal. They could be exculpatory to the president, they could be incriminating to the president. These are certainly not Democratic witnesses or Democratic documents. We want – both of my colleagues said – the truth. And that’s what we’re going to focus on,’ he continued.
In lamenting that Trump is continuing to obstruct Congress by instructing White House staffers not to testify in the impeachment proceedings, Schiff listed the main witnesses the Democrats are interested in calling if they are able to compel individuals to testify in the trial.
At the top of that list is acting White House Chief of Staff Mick Mulvaney and Robert Blair, an aide to Mulvaney who was one of the individuals in the room listening in on Trump’s July 25 phone call with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky.
‘Witnesses with first-hand knowledge of the president’s actions, including his closest aids – some of whom were directly involved in executing the president’s improper orders,’ Schiff said of those Democrats want to hear from in the trial.
‘These witnesses include: Mick Mulvaney and Robert Blair, Russell Vought, the acting head of the Office of Management and Budget, Michael Duffy, a senior official, and the president’s chief legal advisor on the National Security Council, John Eisenberg, among others,’ he listed.
‘The managers will present in detail what these officials knew about their role in executing different parts of the president’s scheme,’ he continued. ‘There’s no dispute, nor could there be, that President Trump’s order substantially obstructed the House impeachment inquiry. That obstruction continues unabated today, even as we stand here at the start of the president’s trial.’
The Senate commenced its impeachment trial Tuesday afternoon with a debate over the rules of the proceedings, including the ability for the prosecution and defense to call witnesses for additional testimony that was not revealed in the House investigation.
Although Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell has expressed his disinterest in calling witnesses and extending the trial, he has vowed to hold a vote after the opening arguments on a potential resolution to allow witnesses.
Republicans have warned Democrats that if witnesses are permitted, some may be called that they do not approve of – like Hunter, who served on the board of a Ukrainian natural gas firm from 2014-2019.
Trump has pushed for Senate Republicans to call the still-anonymous whistle-blower, whose report of the president’s July 25 phone call with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelesnky sparked the events that led to the impeachment inquiry.
The Senate will reconvene Wednesday afternoon for the second day of the impeachment trial where Democrats will get the chance to begin presenting their opening arguments in the Senate impeachment trial Wednesday after they lost more than 10 motions to change the rules of the proceedings.
Starting at 1 p.m. Wednesday afternoon the seven Democratic managers assigned to prosecute the president in the Senate trial will launch their argument for removing Donald Trump from office.
Both sides of the case were able to speak during the first day of the trial Tuesday, and Democrats made the case for why rules outlined by Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell needed to be amended.
Both the prosecution and defense were scolded by Chief Justice John Roberts, who is presiding over the trial, when they began firing insults at each other.
Donald Trump’s lawyers argued that the articles – abuse of power and obstruction of Congress – are not actually impeachable offenses as outlined in the Constitution.
Chief Justice John Roberts, who presiding over the impeachment trial, reprimanded the lawmakers, telling them to ‘avoid speaking in a manner and using language that is not conducive to civil discourse’
Democrats lost a series of rounds when the Senate voted down attempts by Minority Leader Chuck Schumer to subpoena witnesses and a cache of documents.
In the debate, which stretched past 1 a.m., lawmakers voted down Schumer’s proposed amendments in a series of 53-47 strict party line votes in all but one case. This is the same party split that divides the GOP-controlled Senate.
The votes on the proposed rule changes were held back to back on the first day of the president’s impeachment trial.
Democrats attempted to wear down opposition and gain a commitment to call witnesses as votes piled up late into the night.
House Judiciary Committee Chairman Jerry Nadler of New York, sidelined for much of the day’s debate, scolded Republicans, using a term they have labeled of the GOP strategy: ‘cover-up.’
‘The question is whether the Senate will be complicit in the president’s crimes by covering this up?’ he questioned.
He also accused Senate Republicans of participating in ‘a treacherous vote’ he said was ‘against an honest consideration of the evidence against the president. A vote against an honest trial. A vote against the United States.’
‘The only one who should be embarrassed Mr. Nadler, is you, for the way you addressed the United States Senate,’ Trump’s lawyer Pat Cipollone furiously responded.
The clash brought the first public rebuke by Chief Supreme Court Justice John Roberts – who rapped both sides.
‘I think it is appropriate at this point for me to admonish both the House managers and president’s counsel in equal terms to remember that they are addressing the world’s greatest deliberative body,’ said the chief justice, who is presiding over the impeachment trial.
Roberts reminded members to ‘avoid speaking in a manner and using language that is not conducive to civil discourse.’
He cited a 1905 case that brought a ruling against using the term ‘pettifogging’ – or stressing petty details – and said that ‘those addressing the senate should remember where they are.’
Schumer wanted to subpoena documents from the administration related to Trump’s communications with the president of Ukraine and on intra-administration communication on the withholding – and later release – of U.S. military aid to Ukraine. He also wanted White House budget documents about the withheld aid. But his Republican colleagues voted him down – over and over again.
The White House refused to release such documents – including communication between the president and his top national security team – during the House impeachment investigation.
Republicans followed their lead on Tuesday as only the third impeachment trial of a president in history began, with the bitter partisan warfare potentially overshadowing the fact that President Donald John Trump is on trial accused of abusing the power of his office and obstructing Congress.
‘This is midnight!’ fumed Rep. Adam Schiff just a few minutes before the clock struck 12 after hours of charged debates.
In the last, the Senate voted against a Democratic proposal to let the chief justice subpoena witnesses.
‘Why doesn’t the GOP trust the Chief Justice to determine witness relevance? I’ll tell you why, because they want to call Hunter Biden,’ said Schiff, bringing up Joe Biden’s surviving son. ‘What’s his relevance? None. So we have one side who wants a fair trial and one side who’s terrified of a fair trial.’
His trial came hours after senators spoke outside the chamber of the possibility of making a deal on witnesses that would allow Hunter or former Vice President Joe Biden to testify in exchange for testimony by former national security advisor John Bolton or another figure.
Trump’s legal team brought forth a series advocates, from personal lawyers to members of the White House counsel’s office, as well as Trump advisor Pam Bondi, the former Florida attorney general.
Bondi blasted the House impeachment effort, saying: ‘That hypocrisy is astounding.’ She intoned: ‘That’s why we’re here because they started in the secret bunker hearings where the president and his counsel weren’t even allowed to participate when they’re trying to impeach him.’ She called House Intelligence and Judiciary inquiries a ‘one-sided circus.’
Schiff countered that the ‘secret depositions’ allowed 100 lawmakers to participate. Only members of key committees were allowed to take part.
What you can’t see on TV: Mitch McConnell has introduced rules which severely restrict television images from the Senate. Only two shots are shown when impeachment managers or Trump’s attorneys make their case – one focused on the speaker, the other a wider view of the well of the Senate. But this sketch from the gallery of the Senate shows how each senator must stay at their desk for all of the trial
Prosecution and defense: Zoe Lofgren was the second Democrat to speak in favor of subpoenaing White House documents, while Jay Sekulow, the president’s personal attorney, followed Pat Cipollone to the well of the Senate
Head to head: Democratic impeachment manager Hakeem Jeffries, the third-most senior member of the Democratic caucus, makes the case to subpoena Mick Mulvaney, the White House chief of staff, while Trump’s deputy White House counsel Mike Purpura argues against
THE MOTIONS DEMOCRATS LOST 53-47
Demand for evidence from the White House
Demand for evidence from the State Department
Demand for evidence from the Office of Management and Budget
Demand for Mick Mulvaney, the acting White House chief of staff to give evidence
Demand evidence from the Defense Department about delay on security aid to Ukraine
Demand information from White House aide Robert Blair and Office of Management and Budget aide Michael Duffey
Prohibit selective introduction of evidence when information has been subject to a subpoena and allow for review of classified material
Demand testimony by former national security advisor John Bolton
Allow motions to subpoena witnesses after a question period by senators
Allow chief justice to demand probative evidence relative to either impeachment article
As the procedural debate wore on into the night, Schumer introduced another effort – this time a vote on subpoenaing testimony from acting White House Chief of Staff Mick Mulvaney, who has been identified by witnesses as a key player in the decision to withhold aid.
McConnell was forced to change the rules he put forward on Monday night, to give each side three days instead of two to make their cases, after moderate Republican Susan Collins said she wanted the trial to be more like that of Bill Clinton.
That stretched out a timetable that ultra-Trump loyalist congressman Jim Jordan had started the day by scoffing would see him impeached in a week – and every extra day makes McConnell’s high-wire management of the trial more difficult.
And the Washington Post reported that Democrats began to discuss cooking up a deal to offer Hunter Biden as a witness in exchange for evidence from John Bolton, an unexpectedly bold move which could also include Joe Biden. Such an arrangement would scramble McConnell’s plan for no witnesses and call Trump’s bluff after months of tweeting: ‘Where’s Hunter?’
Schumer was able to propose an unlimited number of amendments and each one is eligible for two hours of debate – one hour for each side – but in the end all he may have accomplished is running out the clock.
AND THE SINGLE MOTION THEY LOST 52-48
Allowing subpoenas of witnesses after the Senate’s question period
* Sen. Susan Collins of Maine was the only Republican to defect
In the longer term Democrats broadly will try to use the votes against evidence and witnesses as a line of attack against more marginal Republicans in the November Senate races.
Schiff, a California Democrat who is heading a team of impeachment managers, made his case before 100 senators seated at their desks – telling them they must provide for a ‘fair trial’ that lets each side make its case. But his initial argument, put forward over the rules of the trial themselves, didn’t keep him from digging into the Ukraine affair that constitutes the first article of impeachment against him.
President Trump ‘seeks the full and complete destruction of a co-equal branch of government,’ said Schiff, who played video of Trump saying the Constitution’s Article II gives him the power to ‘do whatever I want.’
Voting time: The tightly-controlled images from the chamber means that senators are only seen when they vote
Republican side: Mitch McConnell unveiled trial rules which would prevent witnesses being called until after senators have asked questions of the prosecution and defense – and Pat Cipollone, the president’s White House counsel and lead attorney, who has never been heard speaking on television before, supported him
All about the Bidens: The trial grows out of Trump’s attempts to get Ukraine to investigate Hunter and Joe Biden over the former vice-president’s son’s role as the director of Burisma, a Ukrainian energy giant, despite having no expertise in energy or ability to speak Ukrainian
Impeachment manager Rep. Val Demmings played a clip of Lev Parnas during the Senate trial to argue additional documents and witnesses are needed
But in one possible concession to push-back, McConnell put forward a rules package allowing for 24 hours of debate for each side spread over three days – rather than two. The earlier timetable would have ensured debates as late as 2 or 3 am.
He made the change under pressure from Sen. Susan Collins of Maine and others – the first indication that McConnell had to trim his preferences to maintain support from a small group of centrists.
Collins, however, has indicated that she will – later in the process – support a Democratic effort to subpoena documents and have additional witnesses.
She also voted with the Democrats once, when they put forward a motion to allow more time for written responses.
But Democrats’ demand for additional witnesses, including acting White House Chief of Staff Mick Mulvaney and former National Security Adviser John Bolton, failed.
House Democrats handed over reams of documents, including voluminous material provided by indicted former Rudy Giuliani associate Lev Parnas, who has said he participated in efforts to get the government of Ukraine to investigate the Bidens.
Parnas turned over such items as a May 2019 letter from Giuliani to Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky seeking a private meeting and saying he was acting with Trump’s ‘knowledge and consent.’
He also turned over photos of himself with Trump, Trump family members, and key Trump World figures. His lawyer says he wants to testify.
Also out of the spotlight will be Trump lawyer Giuliani. He was left off the president’s dozen-strong legal team, having spent months arguing the president’s case on television.
THE TRUMP DREAM TEAM: WHO’S DEFENDING PRESIDENT IN SENATE
Lead counsel: Pat Cipollone, White House Counsel
Millionaire conservative Catholic father-of-10 who has little courtroom experience. ‘Strong, silent,’ type who has earned praise from Trump’s camp for resisting Congress’ investigations of the Ukraine scandal. Critics accused him of failing in his duty as a lawyer by writing ‘nonsense letters’ to reject Congressional oversight. His background is commercial litigation and as White House counsel is the leader of the Trump administration’s drive to put conservative judges in federal courts. Trump has already asked aides behind the scenes if he will perform well on television.
Jay Sekulow, president’s personal attorney
Millionaire one-time IRS prosecutor with his own talk radio show. Self-described Messianic Jew who was counsel to Jews for Jesus. Longtime legal adviser to Trump, but he is himself mentioned in the Ukraine affair, with Lev Parnas saying that he knew about Rudy Giuliani’s attempts to dig dirt on the Bidens but did not approve. Michael Cohen claimed that Sekulow and other members of Trump’s legal team put falsehoods in his statement to the House intel committee; Sekulow denies it. The New York Times reported that he voted for Hillary Clinton.
Alan Dershowitz, Harvard law professor
Shot to worldwide fame for his part in the ‘dream team’s’ successful defense of OJ Simpson but was already famous for his defense of Claus von Bulow, the British socialite accused of murdering his wife in Rhode Island. Ron Silver played Dershowitz in Reversal of Fortune. In 2008 he was a member of Jeffrey Epstein’s legal team which secured the lenient plea deal from federal prosecutors. But Dershowitz was a longtime friend of Epstein and was accused of having sex with two of Esptein’s victims. He denies it and is suing one of them, Virginia Roberts Giuffre, for libel, saying his sex life is ‘perfect.’ He admits he received a massage at Epstein’s home – but ‘kept my underwear on.’ Registered Democrat who spoke out against Trump’s election and again after the Charlottesville violence. Has become an outspoken defender of Trump against the Robert Mueller probe and the Ukraine investigation.
Ken Starr, former Whitewater independent counsel
Famous and reviled in equal measure for his Whitewater investigation into Bill and Hillary Clinton’s finances in Arkansas which eventually led him to evidence of Bill’s affair with Monica Lewinsky. He was a federal appeals judge and George H.W. Bush’s solicitor general before that role. He later became president and chancellor of Baylor University in Waco but was removed as president in May 2016 for mishandling the investigation into allegations of multiple sexual assaults by football players and other students, then quit voluntarily as chancellor. Is the second Jeffrey Epstein defender on the team; he was present in 2008 when the plea deal with prosecutor Alex Acosta was made which let Epstein off with just 13 months of work release prison.
Pam Bondi, White House attorney
Florida’s first female attorney general and also a long-time TV attorney who has been a Fox News guest host – including co-hosting The Five for three days in a row while still attorney general. Began her career as a prosecutor before moving into elected politics. Has been hit by a series of controversies, among them persuading then Florida governor Rick Scott to change the date of an execution because it clashed with her re-election launch, and has come under fire for her association with Scientology. She has defended it saying the group were helping her efforts against human trafficking; at the time the FBI was investigating it over human trafficking. Went all-in on Trump in 2016, leading ‘lock her up’ chants at the 2016 Republican National Convention. Joined the White House last November to aid the anti-impeachment effort.
Robert Ray, Ken Starr’s successor
Headed the Office of the Independent Counsel from 1999 until it closed for business in 2002, meaning it was he, not Ken Starr, who wrote the final words on the scandals of the Clinton years. Those included the report on Monica Lewinsky, the report on the savings and loan misconduct claims which came to be known as Whitewater, and the report on Travelgate, the White House travel office’s firing and file-gate, claims of improper access to the FBI’s background reports. Struck deal with Clinton to give up his law license. Went into private practice. Was charged with stalking a former lover in New York in 2006 four months after she ended their relationship. Now a frequent presence on Fox News.
Jane Raskin, private attorney
Part of a husband-and-wife Florida law team, she is a former prosecutor who specializes in defending in white collar crime cases. Their connection to Trump appears to have been through Ty Cobb, the former White House attorney. She and husband Martin advised Trump on his response to Mueller and appear to have been focused on avoiding an obstruction of justice accusation. That may be the reason to bring her in to the impeachment team; Democrats raised the specter of reviving Mueller’s report in their evidence to the impeachment trial.
Patrick Philbin and Michael Purpura, Deputy White House Counsels
Lowest-profile of the team, they work full-time for Cipollone in the White House. Philbin (left) was a George W. Bush appointee at the Department of Justice who helped come up with the system of trying Guantanamo Bay detainees in front of military commissions instead of in U.S. courts. He was one a group of officials, led by James Comey, who rushed to seriously-ill John Ashcroft’s bedside to stop the renewal of the warrant-less wiretap program. Unknown if Trump is aware of his links to Comey. Purpura (right) is also a Bush White House veteran who shaped its response to Congressional investigations at a time when there were calls for him to be impeached over going to war in Iraq. His name is on letters telling State Department employees not to testify. Has been named as a possible Trump nominee for federal court in Hawaii.
THE IMPEACHMENT MANAGERS: MEET THE SEVEN DEMOCRATS PROSECUTING DONALD TRUMP
Adam Schiff of California: The chairman of the House Intelligence Committee, 59, led the impeachment process against Donald Trump. He became a frequent target of Trump’s fury: the president called him ‘Liddle’ Adam Schiff and made fun of his neck. But Schiff won praise for his leadership during witnesses hearings. Schiff served in the California State Assembly and was a federal prosecutor in the U.S. Attorney’s Office in Los Angeles for six years. He oversaw the prosecution of Richard Miller, the first FBI agent ever to be indicted for espionage. Elected to Congress in 2012.
Jerry Nadler of New York: The Chairman of the House Judiciary Committee, 72, led the series of hearings that developed the two articles of impeachment against the president: abuse of power and obstruction of justice. He’s in his 15th term in Congress and was a New York State Assembly man before joining Capitol Hill. He was in law school when he was first elected to state office and completed his J.D. while serving in Albany. He and Schiff were expected to be named. Elected to Congress in 1992.
Zoe Lofgren of California: A close Nancy Pelosi ally and a long time friend of the speaker, Lofgren, 72, has the unique experience of playing a role in three presidential impeachment proceedings: as a Judiciary Committee staffer during Richard Nixon’s in 1974, as a Judiciary Committee Member during Bill Clinton’s 1999 impeachment, and now in President Trump’s. Additionally, she heads the Committee on House Administration, a position that has the moniker ‘Mayor of Capitol Hill’ given the panel’s jurisdiction over the everyday running of the Capitol, including members’ allowance, office space, and rules of the House. Elected to Congress in 1994.
Hakeem Jeffries of New York: Jeffries, 49, was a litigator in private practice before running for elected office. He worked in the litigation department of Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & Garrison before becoming assistant litigator for Viacom and CBS, where he worked on litigation stemming from the Super Bowl XXXVIII halftime show controversy, when Janet Jackson’s breast, adorned with a nipple shield, was exposed by Justin Timberlake for about half a second, in what was later referred to as a ‘wardrobe malfunction’. The Federal Election Commission fined CBS $550,000 after a long legal case. The Chair of the House Democratic Caucus, Jeffries serves on the House Judiciary Committee. Before Congress, he was in the New York State Assembly for six years. Elected to Congress in 2012 and a member of the House Judiciary Committee.
Val Demings of Florida: Demings, 62, served in the Orlando Police Department for 27 years, including serving as the city’s first female chief of police. She is one of seven children born in poverty – her father worked in Florida orange groves and her mother was a housekeeper. She was the first member of her family graduate from college. She worked as a social worker before joining the Orlando police department. A member of the House Intelligence panel and the Judiciary Committee, Demings won plaudits for her careful questioning of witnesses during the impeachment hearings. She wrote on Twitter in December, during the impeachment process: ‘I am a descendant of slaves, who knew that they would not make it, but dreamed and prayed that one day I would make it. So despite America’s complicated history, my faith is in the Constitution. I’ve enforced the laws, and now I write the laws. Nobody is above the law.’ She spends her free time riding her Harley-Davidson Road King Classic motorcycle. Elected to Congress in 2016.
Jason Crow of Colorado: Crow, 40, was an Army Ranger in Iraq and Afghanistan, where he served three tours and was awarded a Bronze Star. He was a private litigator with the Holland and Hart Law Firm before running for Congress. He was elected to Congress in 2018 and serves on the House Armed Services Committee.
Sylvia Garcia of Texas: Garcia, 69, has a strong judicial background. She was the director and presiding judge of the Houston Municipal System and was elected city controller. She was also the first Hispanic and first woman to be elected in her own right to the Harris County Commissioner’s Court. Elected to Congress in 2018, she serves on the House Judiciary Committee.
Plane full of passengers from coronavirus epicentre in China lands in Sydney
I’m a Celebrity: ‘Petrified’ Dale Thomas breaks down over snake phobia
Cancer con Belle Gibson seen at Melbourne Ethiopian community meeting
Axon adds license plate recognition to police dash cams, but heeds ethics board’s concerns
Nick Giannopoulos warns other comedians to stop using the word ‘wog’
69 Canadians to give up holidays at home, head to Australia to battle wildfires
Tech3 months ago
Axon adds license plate recognition to police dash cams, but heeds ethics board’s concerns
Entertainment2 months ago
Nick Giannopoulos warns other comedians to stop using the word ‘wog’
News1 month ago
69 Canadians to give up holidays at home, head to Australia to battle wildfires
News2 months ago
Police arrest one of two men wanted over hit-and-run death of mother
News2 weeks ago
Zoo visitor faces losing her arm after she was mauled by a jaguar
News3 months ago
Metal detectorist, 42, unearths £100,000 haul of 500-year-old gold coins
Entertainment2 months ago
Kanye West brings Sunday Service to a Texas jail days before controversial Joel Osteen meeting
News3 months ago
Rapper T.I. has a doctor check his daughter’s hymen every year to ensure she’s a virgin